Aston Villa penalty debate rages on as opposition player makes brutally honest confession
Aston Villa were undone for the first time in the Champions League as Club Brugges took advantage of a controversial penalty, which saw Tyrone Mings pick the ball up from a goal kick
by Neil Moxley · The MirrorSimon Mignolet said keepers and defenders must wise up to avoid the situation that cost Aston Villa dear.
The former Liverpool shot-stopper, now playing between the sticks for Brugges, was at the other end of the pitch as a mix-up between Emi Martinez and Tyrone Mings saw Unai Emery ’s side fall to a 1-0 defeat.
Villa sacrificed their 100 per cent record in the competition so far when the Argentine keeper took a goal-kick in the 52nd minute, gently tapping the ball to just outside the corner of the six-yard box only for the defender to reach down and stop it with his hand.
Brugges players and the crowd appealed and referee Tobias Stieler pointed to the spot. The England centre-half clearly believed it wasn’t in play. The match official deemed that it was. Hans Vanaken gleefully accepted the unexpected present by netting from the spot, leaving Villa to nurse their first defeat in four Champions League outings.
The controversy mirrored that which took place in April when Arsenal ’s David Raya and defender Gabriel got into a similar mix-up, infuriating then Bayern boss Thomas Tuchel. The referee that night, Glenn Nyberg said that it was ‘a kid’s mistake’ and refused to censure the Gunners’ defender. Stieler took the opposite view, that the ball was in play.
Mignolet watched the drama unfold from the opposite end and said: “I’m aware of it. I always try to throw the ball to my defender at goal kicks. You never know, if the ball is outside the six-yard box and the defender touches the ball the goal-kick has been taken.
“I don’t know how the rule is decided. You don’t know how the referee is going to interpret these kind of things. But there’s a reason why we throw the ball. Sometimes when you rush yourself, it goes a little bit quick, and part of doing it out of habit you kick the ball to him, then it depends how the referee is going to interpret it.
“There is also the debate that if you kick it to him and you haven’t re-started and an attacker comes to press…then it works both ways. That’s why I throw the ball, so this doesn’t happen. It’s very harsh but I am very lucky I was on the right end of it."
Mignolet felt that Brugges were value for their win, despite the unexpected nature of it. He added: “The goal was a gift but we deserved it in terms of chances. Aston Villa are a really strong team and we tried to play it tactically, close between the lines, we didn’t give any space to them in attack because they have got some players who can make a difference.
“The scenario turned out well - we scored in the right moment and then we could be dangerous on the counter attack. “They never created the chances they needed to score an equaliser.”
Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
Sky Sports deal
Sky Sports launches discounted Premier League package
£46 (was £56)
Sky has slashed the price of its Sky Sports, Sky Stream, Sky TV and Netflix bundle in an unbeatable new deal that saves £240 and includes 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.