Vicious XL Bullies tore chunks out of woman's arm as she screamed for help
by Wesley Holmes · Manchester Evening NewsThe owner of two aggressive XL Bullies that brutally attacked a woman was seen crying in court as CCTV footage of the incident was played. 24-year-old Kelis Smith pleaded guilty to two counts of being in charge of a dog dangerously out of control causing injury after her pets, Kodak and Love, mauled the woman in the middle of the street.
On May 15 last year, around 10pm, Smith, who resides at Brock Hall Close, Clock Face in St Helens, had let her three dogs into the communal garden of her flat. One of the dogs returned, but Kodak, an XL Bully, and Love, an XLB cross, managed to escape through a gate Smith knew was faulty and wandered onto a nearby street where Katie Elliot was walking.
At 10.55pm, CCTV footage from a neighbouring garden showed the two dogs approaching Miss Elliot, 22, and launching their attack. The mother-of-three was pulled to the ground where she was shaken, dragged and bitten multiple times.
Prosecutor Cecilia Pritchard, speaking at Liverpool Crown Court today, November 6, said: "Local residents had been alerted to the incident because they could hear her screaming for help, and a number of them came out. Despite numerous attempts to get the dogs off, it was not having any real effect."
"What some people said... is that they had tried to hit the dogs repeatedly with sticks - some of them had broken. This obviously didn't cause the dogs - particularly the larger dog, Kodak - to desist, and that dog was still trying to drag the victim along the ground even after the intervention of these people. One of the males said when he was trying to intervene, the dog was also trying to bite him. Another said that despite hitting Kodak as hard as he could with the stick, this had very little effect and the dog continued to shake and drag the victim.", reports the Liverpool Echo.
(Image: Merseyside police)
Smith broke down in tears as the video footage showed the group of people desperately trying to halt the attack on Miss Elliot - with one individual even driving his car towards the dogs in an attempt to frighten them away. Miss Elliot sustained severe injuries to her shoulder, chest and upper limbs, including a "massive degloving injury" to her right arm, which was bitten down to the bone.
She required multiple skin graft surgeries, and the court heard she continued to suffer from pain and mobility issues more than a year later.
The assault lasted approximately five minutes, and Miss Elliot was taken into a resident's house while Kodak was returned to Smith, who had gone out searching for the dogs. The other dog, Love, was later discovered by police, and Smith was subsequently arrested.
Ms Pritchard explained, "She said that neither dog had been previously aggressive, albeit neither had been to any training classes. Kodak is an XL Bully, and Love is the offspring of Kodak and the other dog, Daisy."
In defence, Paul Davidson remarked, "The defendant made full and frank admissions and was extremely remorseful about what had happened. She says to me it was made clear from a very early stage that the injuries were such that she may well face a prison sentence. To have that hanging over her head for a year has been very distressing for her."
"The defendant returned home from work to let the dogs out. It was late at night. She had, earlier that day, discovered the gate to the communal garden was faulty and had purchased a padlock. She hadn't yet put that padlock on that gate. The dogs had never before shown any aggression. The neighbours had never complained."
"She's extremely remorseful and tearful. She said 'If I had known my dogs were hurting someone, I would have stopped it'."
Furthermore, he added: "Clearly, given the nature of the offences, the dogs will be destroyed. She concedes the destruction of the dogs is partly her decision and she doesn't object."
"Despite the nature of the offence, the defendant asks that the court find that she is a fit and proper person (to have custody of a dog). There is one other dog, Daisy, who was not involved. That's also the defendant's dog and she would like to keep that dog and other dogs in future."
Judge Ian Harris stated: "This was a ferocious attack. The victim's screams were heard by her sister, to whom she was speaking on her mobile phone just before the attack. On CCTV you can distinctively hear Miss Elliot's screams. She has said she thought she would die."
In sentencing Smith to 12 months in prison, he added: "Your behaviour, so far as control of the dogs was concerned, was criminally irresponsible. You took no steps to ensure they were under control and they caused dreadful, life-long effects to the victim."
Smith, who appeared in court wearing a large, black sports hoodie, showed no emotion as she was jailed - but became visibly upset when the judge announced that the dogs, Kodak and Love, would be destroyed. He also banned her from owning dogs for 24 months.